Florida has more homeowners' associations than nearly any state in the country, and the disputes they generate can move from a fine notice to a threatened lien in a matter of months. The question most homeowners arrive with is whether their HOA actually had the legal authority to do what it did. Under Florida law, that question has a structured answer.
Florida's Homeowners' Association Act, found in Chapter 720 of the Florida Statutes, governs HOA operations throughout the state. The law authorizes HOAs to enforce the community's declaration of covenants, conditions, and restrictions, levy assessments, and adopt and enforce reasonable rules. Every HOA derives its specific authority from its governing documents, meaning the declaration, bylaws, and rules approved for that particular community. If a restriction or action is not authorized by those documents or by Chapter 720, the HOA's legal footing is questionable.
Under Florida Statute 720.305, an HOA can levy fines for covenant violations, but the process has specific requirements. The fine cannot exceed $100 per violation and $1,000 in total for a continuing violation unless the governing documents allow more. Fines below $1,000 cannot become a lien on the property. Before a fine can be imposed, the HOA must give the homeowner at least 14 days' written notice and the opportunity to appear before an independent fining committee. That committee must consist of at least three members who are not board members, officers, or employees of the association. If the committee does not approve the fine by a majority vote, the fine cannot be imposed. Many homeowners are unaware this process exists.
An HOA's lien rights apply to unpaid assessments, not to fines below the statutory threshold. When dues or special assessments go unpaid, Chapter 720 permits the association to record a lien against the property and, in some circumstances, pursue foreclosure. The rules governing that process, including notice requirements and the amount outstanding needed to proceed, are set out in the statute and in the association's governing documents. A homeowner facing a lien or foreclosure threat has procedural protections and, in some cases, grounds to challenge the amount claimed or the process used to pursue it.
Florida's legislature has enacted significant HOA reforms in recent years. Legislation passed in 2024 added new requirements for HOA boards and managers, including restrictions on certain fee types, mandatory records access, and criminal penalties for board members who knowingly and intentionally violate specific provisions of the law. These reforms expanded the accountability tools available to homeowners and created new grounds to challenge HOA conduct that does not comply with the updated statute.
The first step is reviewing the governing documents to determine whether the HOA's action was authorized by the declaration or bylaws. If a fine notice arrives, participating in the fining committee hearing is both a right and an opportunity. If the dispute involves assessments, liens, or board conduct that appears to exceed statutory authority, the analysis becomes more detailed. In any action between a homeowner and an HOA, the prevailing party may recover attorney fees under Florida law, which changes the practical calculus for both sides. Borell Law has assisted clients throughout Florida with HOA-related civil disputes and covenant enforcement matters for more than 36 years.
This is general information, not legal advice. Every case is unique; consult your Florida attorney first.
Free Consultation: 1-888-503-5555
Follow us on social media.
